Steel vs. Aluminum Garage Doors: What’s Best for Your Home?

Choosing the best garage door for your home requires careful thought, especially since there are so many options on the market. Most of the time, steel and aluminum garage doors are the most popular and always get the attention of smart homeowners. These two materials are the best because they have different benefits and qualities that make them stand out. 

In the next section, we’ll talk about the subtle differences and differences between steel and aluminum. This will give homeowners a better understanding of the two materials and help them make a decision that fits their home’s functional needs and aesthetic goals.

Characteristics of Aluminum Garage Doors:

Aluminum is a material that is known for being very light and resistant to corrosion, especially in places with a lot of salt. Aluminum garage doors have many benefits that come from their natural qualities.

  • Weight: Aluminum garage doors are much lighter than steel ones. This clear difference in weight takes the pressure off the working parts, which could make the door’s opening system last longer.
  • Corrosion Resistance: The fact that aluminum doesn’t rust may be particularly helpful for people who live near the coast or in areas with much humidity.
  • Design Flexibility: Because aluminum is easy to shape, it can be used in various forms, from the most modern to the most classic.
  • Cost-effectiveness: In terms of money, aluminum doors usually have a lower starting cost than their steel counterparts.

Characteristics of Steel Garage Doors:

Steel is known for its high tensile strength and long-lasting quality, both mirrored in the benefits of steel garage doors.

  • Sturdiness: Steel garage doors are carefully made to withstand much force. This makes them especially resistant to dents and other damage from everyday exchanges or accidents.
  • Insulating Options: Steel doors often come with a variety of insulating options. These not only make the door better at keeping heat in, but they also make it stronger.
  • Aesthetic variety: Modern steel garage doors can have detailed wood grain patterns or a smooth veneer to make them look more elegant. Also, they can be colored in many different ways to fit in with the rest of the house’s design.
  • Durability: Steel doors can last long if they are well cared for. They can withstand the natural effects of wear and tear for a long time.

Comparing the Benefits

After discussing the different benefits of steel and aluminum garage doors, it’s important to compare the two to clarify the comparison.

  • Durability and Tenacity: There’s no question that both materials are durable. On the other hand, steel garage doors are usually more resistant to damage because of how they are made. Steel might be a better choice for homes where the garage door might get bumped or hit accidentally.
  • Upkeep: Part of the appeal of aluminum garage doors is that they don’t need as much care as other types of doors. This is because aluminum is naturally rust-resistant, especially in certain climates. On the other hand, rust can be stopped by galvanizing or treating steel doors in certain ways.
  • Thermal Proficiency: When insulation is added to a steel garage door, it serves two purposes: it makes the door stronger and keeps the garage at a constant temperature, which could lead to energy savings.
  • Considerations about money: Aluminum garage doors usually cost less to buy at first. But the durability of steel and the benefits that come with it over time may cancel out the initial cost savings that aluminum offers over the life of the door.

Factors To Consider When Choosing Between Steel and Aluminum Garage Doors

When choosing a material for your garage door, you usually have to choose between steel and metal garage doors. Both materials have benefits, but knowing the differences can help you make a better choice.

Steel garage doors are known for being sturdy and long-lasting. They are less likely to get dents and can withstand bad weather, making them perfect for homes that want something that will last for a long time. Steel doors also come in a wide range of colors and shapes, so you can make them look exactly how you want.

On the other hand, metal garage doors are lighter, which can be suitable for the parts that raise and lower the door, possibly making them last longer. Aluminum is naturally immune to rust, making it an excellent choice for homes near the coast or in humid areas. Its ability to be shaped also lets it be used in various shapes and finishes.

So, aluminum or steel? The answer varies a lot on each person’s preferences and the situation. If you want something strong and flexible in how it looks, steel might be your best option. But metal could be the better option if rust resistance and lighter weight are the most critical factors. Before making a final choice, you should always talk to a professional to ensure your garage door meets your needs and expectations.


Your choice between steel and aluminum garage doors depends on your specific needs, aesthetic preferences, and budget. Both materials offer a plethora of advantages. Aluminum might be your go-to if you seek a lightweight, rust-resistant, and cost-effective solution. However, a steel door might be more apt if you prioritize strength, durability, and potential energy savings.

Always consult with garage door professionals when making your decision to ensure the best fit for your home and to gain a more profound understanding of the idiosyncrasies of each material.


At LMS Garage Doors, we’re proud to have the best selection of high-quality steel and metal garage doors that are carefully made to fit any architectural style. From simple, modern patterns to timeless, classic ones, our collection is made to suit a wide range of tastes and preferences.

We know that every homeowner has different needs, so we’ve put together a range that makes your home look better from the outside and fits with different budgets. Every garage door in our collection comes with a promise of quality, longevity, and long-term performance. This makes sure that every dollar you spend is worth it.

But we’re also committed to making great garage doors. Our team of hardworking pros is the heart of LMS Garage Doors. Our staff has years of experience and can help you through every step of the selection process. This way, you can be sure to make an informed choice that fits the needs of your house.

We’re here to help, whether you’re just starting to think about your choices or have specific questions about a particular model for your new garage door projects. Fill out our online contact form for a smooth process and quick answers to all your questions. You can trust LMS Garage Doors to help you find the right metal door for your house.



advanced divider

At LMS Garage Doors, we believe in building strong relationships with our customers—and that starts with being honest and upfront about what we can do for you. We are committed to customer satisfaction from start to finish: from providing an estimate that includes all costs involved with installing a new garage door system (including materials) to working with local contractors if necessary; from installing the system in a timely fashion; and finally, to providing ongoing support after the installation is complete.


Someone will get in touch with you soon to confirm your exact appointment time.