The Ultimate Guide to Replacing Garage Door Panels: Key Considerations for a Seamless Upgrade

garage door panel

‍Garage doors play a vital role in enhancing the security, aesthetics, and functionality of a property. Over time, wear and tear can take a toll on the garage door panels, compromising their performance and appearance. Replacing garage door panels is an essential maintenance task that ensures the door continues to function optimally and enhances the overall curb appeal of your home.

Many homeowners with residential garage doors frequently ask if they can replace just one panel of the door, especially when the damage is not extensive, to avoid the cost of a full door replacement. 

The simple answer is yes, it is possible, but this option is subject to various conditions. In the following article, we’ll delve into these conditions and explain when it becomes essential to involve a professional in garage door repair.

What are Garage Door Panels?

Garage door panels are the segments found immediately below the door’s windows. In the absence of windows, these panels are the broad horizontal or vertical sections that form the entirety of the door. The total number of panels a garage door has depends on its style and size. When choosing a fully-customized garage door, you can select as many (or as few) panels as desired for your specific design.

Garage Door Panel Style Options

When selecting garage door panels, there is a vast array of styles available. This article highlights the diverse range of panel options offered by Artisan. It’s important to note that these options vary across different product lines and may not be available for every door model. Here’s a breakdown and explanation of our current panel selections:

Beaded Panels 

(Wood or Vinyl)

These panels feature a series of raised beads or ridges, adding texture and visual interest. Available in both wood and vinyl materials.

Beaded Tongue and Groove Panels

(Wood or Vinyl)

Similar to beaded panels but with a tongue and groove construction, providing a more snug fit and a distinctive style. Offered in wood and vinyl.

Flat Composite Wood Panels

(Paint-Grade Only)

Made of composite wood, these panels are flat and smooth, ideal for painting to match your home’s exterior.

Flat Solid Wood Panels

Constructed from a single type of wood, these panels provide a classic, seamless look.

Flat Vinyl or Urethane Panels

These are smooth panels made from either vinyl or urethane, known for their durability and low maintenance.

Flush Tongue and Groove Wood Panels

These wood panels fit together seamlessly, offering a flush, uniform surface.

Glass Panels in Aluminum Frames

These panels consist of glass set in aluminum frames, adding a modern touch and allowing natural light.

Raised Composite Wood Panels

(Paint-Grade Only)

Raised panels made of composite wood, designed for painting, give a dimensional appearance.

Raised Flush Tongue and Groove Solid Wood Panels

(Over 12” Wide)

These are wide, solid wood panels with a raised, flush tongue and groove design, providing a distinctive, robust appearance.

Raised Solid Wood Panels

(Under 12” Wide)

Narrower than the above, these raised panels offer a traditional wood look.

Raised Vinyl Panels

These vinyl panels have a raised design, offering texture and a contemporary feel.

Raised Recessed Panels 

(Also Known as Simulated Raised Panels)

These panels have a recessed area, creating the illusion of a raised panel.

V-Groove Panels

(Wood, Urethane, or Vinyl)

Characterized by a “V” shaped groove, these panels add a unique visual element. Available in wood, urethane, or vinyl.

V-Groove Tongue and Groove Panels

(Wood, Urethane, or Vinyl)

Combining the V-groove design with a tongue and groove construction for a snug fit and an enhanced look. Offered in various materials.

When do I need to get new garage door panels?

Determining if your garage door requires panel replacement hinges on several unique factors related to your situation. These include the age of the door, the severity of the damage, and the specific design of your garage door.

The age of your garage door is a significant factor in assessing its condition. If your door is nearing or has surpassed its expected lifespan, replacing it might be more economical than continuous repairs.

The extent of damage to the door is another critical factor. Minor damage confined to small areas might only need repairs for full functionality restoration. However, extensive or structural damage might necessitate a full door replacement.

Lastly, your garage door’s design plays a vital role. Certain designs may be more susceptible to damage or wear and tear. In such cases, considering a replacement can be a wise choice to ensure your new door is better equipped to handle your garage’s specific conditions and deliver dependable performance over time.

Popular Garage Door Panels Styles

When choosing garage door panels, it’s crucial to match them with your home’s architectural style. Here’s a guide to the most common garage door panel styles:

Raised Panel Garage Doors

A popular choice for both traditional and contemporary homes, raised panel doors feature decorative elements that add depth and visual interest. These panels can be short (side-by-side across the door) or long (running the entire length of the door), enhancing the home’s curb appeal.

Recessed Panel Garage Doors

These panels are sunken into the door’s surface, often created using overlay techniques. Available in short, long, and flush options, recessed panels offer a traditional look with a modern twist.

Carriage-Style Panel Garage Doors

Central to carriage house-style doors, these panels are more ornate, featuring detailed trim boards in various designs (cross, X, V, Z). They often come with decorative accessories like handles and latches, adding a classic charm.

Flush Panel Garage Doors

Ideal for a modern, minimalist aesthetic, flush panels are entirely flat, often with minimal texturing or windows. This style allows the home itself to stand out, offering a clean and understated look.

Each style offers unique visual appeal, so consider your home’s design and your personal preferences when choosing.

Key considerations before replacing garage door panels

Before embarking on the process of replacing garage door panels, several key considerations should be considered. Firstly, determine the compatibility of the replacement panels with your existing garage door system. Check the dimensions, design, and material to ensure a seamless fit. Secondly, consider the climate in your area.

If you live in an environment prone to extreme temperatures or high humidity, choose panels that can withstand these conditions. Additionally, assess your budget and choose panels that balance affordability and quality. 

Finally, evaluate your own DIY skills and determine if the replacement process is something you can handle or if it is best left to professionals.

How to measure and choose the correct replacement panels

Accurate measurements are crucial when replacing garage door panels. Start by measuring the width, height, and thickness of the existing panels. Take multiple measurements at different points to ensure accuracy. When choosing replacement panels, match the dimensions precisely to ensure a proper fit. 

Consider the style and color of the panels to ensure they complement the overall aesthetics of your property. It is advisable to consult with a garage door specialist to ensure you select the right panels for your specific needs.

Step-by-step guide to replacing garage door panels

Replacing garage door panels may seem daunting, but with the right guidance, it can be a straightforward process. Here is a step-by-step guide to help you through the replacement process:

  1. Begin by disconnecting the garage door opener and securing the door in the open position.
  2. Remove the existing panels by unscrewing the hinges and carefully detaching them from the track.
  3. Install the new panels by aligning them with the track and attaching the hinges securely.
  4. Check the balance of the door and adjust the tension of the springs if necessary.
  5. Test the door’s operation to ensure smooth functionality.
  6. Paint or finish the panels according to your preference to enhance their appearance and protect them from the elements.

Common challenges and troubleshooting tips during the replacement process

While replacing garage door panels, you may encounter some common challenges. The panels may not align correctly, leading to an uneven door operation. In such cases, carefully adjust the hinges and track alignment. Another challenge is improper tension in the springs, causing the door to be too heavy or too light. Adjust the tension accordingly to achieve optimal balance. If you face any difficulties during the replacement process, it is advisable to consult a professional for guidance and assistance.

Benefits of hiring a professional for garage door panel replacement

While replacing garage door panels can be a DIY project, there are several advantages to hiring a professional. Professionals have the expertise and experience to handle the replacement process efficiently and safely. They can ensure precise measurements, proper alignment, and correct installation, avoiding any potential issues that may arise from incorrect installation. Hiring a professional also saves you time and effort, allowing you to focus on other important tasks.

Cost considerations for replacing garage door panels

The cost of replacing garage door panels can vary depending on various factors such as the material, size, and complexity of the panels. Steel and aluminum panels tend to be more affordable compared to wood or fiberglass. Additionally, if you choose to hire a professional for the replacement, labor costs will be a factor to consider. It is advisable to obtain multiple quotes from reputable garage door specialists to compare prices and choose the option that fits your budget while maintaining quality.

Conclusion: Enjoying a seamless upgrade with new garage door panels

Replacing garage door panels is a crucial step in maintaining the functionality and appearance of your garage door. By recognizing the signs that indicate the need for replacement, understanding the different types of panels available, and considering key factors such as compatibility and budget, you can ensure a seamless upgrade. Whether you choose to handle the replacement yourself or hire a professional, the result will be a garage door that operates smoothly, enhances the curb appeal of your property, and provides the security and convenience you desire.

Contact LMS Garage Doors Today

For professional assistance with replacing your garage door panels, contact LMS Garage Doors. Our team of experts is dedicated to providing high-quality garage door service in Sacramento, CA and ensuring a seamless replacement process. 

Contact us today or visit our website at to schedule a consultation and experience the difference of working with trusted professionals.



advanced divider

At LMS Garage Doors, we believe in building strong relationships with our customers—and that starts with being honest and upfront about what we can do for you. We are committed to customer satisfaction from start to finish: from providing an estimate that includes all costs involved with installing a new garage door system (including materials) to working with local contractors if necessary; from installing the system in a timely fashion; and finally, to providing ongoing support after the installation is complete.


Someone will get in touch with you soon to confirm your exact appointment time.